Wire liveTHEPLANNINGMODEL bureau · all times UTC · copy moves as filed
FiledTHEPLANNINGMODEL · NOV 20, 2026, 19:55

What to discuss with a prospective advice-only financial planner

Getting the conversation started

When you are looking for someone to provide independent financial advice, the first meeting sets the tone for everything that follows. In an advice-only model, the planner does not sell products or earn commissions from anything you buy. That changes the nature of the discussion entirely. Instead of talking about funds or policies, you focus on your situation, your goals, and how the planner will work with you over time. Knowing what to ask and what to look for during that initial conversation helps you decide whether the relationship is right for you.

Understanding the advice-only approach

An advice-only financial planner charges a fee for their time and expertise, not for placing a product. That means the recommendations you receive should be driven entirely by what suits your circumstances, not by what earns the planner a commission. During your first meeting, ask how the planner structures their fees. Some charge by the hour, some by project, and others via a retainer. There is no single correct model, but you want to understand the cost before you commit to anything. A good planner will be transparent about their charges and explain what you get for your money.

The conversation should also cover what happens after you pay the fee. Does the planner provide written recommendations? Do they help you implement those recommendations, or is that your responsibility? In an advice-only arrangement, the planner typically stays out of the implementation process, leaving you free to choose how to act on the advice. You might decide to handle things yourself, or you might bring the recommendations to another professional. Either way, the advice itself remains impartial.

Clarifying the scope of work

Before you go too deep, it helps to agree on what the planner will cover. Some planners offer a comprehensive review of your entire financial life: cash flow, investments, tax planning, insurance, estate planning, and retirement projections. Others specialise in one or two areas. Ask directly about the scope of the work they propose. A clear scope prevents misunderstandings later and ensures you get the independent financial advice you actually need.

At the same time, discuss how the planner gathers information. Most will ask you to complete a detailed fact find before the meeting. That document covers your income, expenses, assets, liabilities, risk tolerance, and goals. The quality of the fact finding process matters because the recommendations that follow are only as good as the data they are based on. If the planner skips this step or rushes through it, consider that a red flag.

Discussing your goals and priorities

Your goals are the reason you are seeking advice in the first place. A skilled planner will spend time exploring what you really want, not just what you think you should want. They might ask about major life events you are planning, such as buying a home, changing careers, or supporting children through education. They may also ask about less tangible things, like what a comfortable retirement looks like to you or how you feel about leaving an inheritance. These questions help the planner tailor their recommendations to your values, not just your numbers.

During the conversation, notice whether the planner listens more than they talk. A planner who immediately jumps into solutions without understanding your situation may be more interested in selling a product than in giving sound advice. The best planners ask thoughtful questions and let you do most of the talking in the first meeting.

Reviewing the planner’s process

Every planner has a process for turning your information into a plan. Ask about their typical timeline. How long does it take to produce the written recommendations? Will you receive a draft to review before the final version? Do they offer a follow-up meeting to explain the recommendations in detail? A clear process gives you confidence that the work will be thorough and that you will have time to ask questions.

Some planners include a review meeting as part of their standard service. Others charge separately for ongoing reviews. If you expect your situation to change - for example, if you are approaching retirement or expecting a change in income - it may be worth paying for a planner who offers periodic check-ins. During the first meeting, ask how the planner handles changes in your circumstances after the initial plan is delivered.

Assessing how the planner communicates

Financial planning involves complex topics, but a good planner can explain those topics in plain language. Pay attention to how the planner speaks during your first meeting. Do they use jargon without explaining it? Do they check that you understand what they are saying? Clear client communication is essential because you need to feel confident making decisions based on the advice you receive.

You may also want to ask how the planner prefers to communicate between meetings. Do they respond to emails quickly? Do they offer phone calls or video calls? Some planners use a secure client portal where you can upload documents and ask questions. Knowing how communication works helps you decide whether the planner’s style fits your preferences.

Evaluating decision support and action plans

Good advice does not just tell you what to do; it helps you understand the trade-offs involved in each decision. During your first meeting, ask how the planner presents different options. Do they show you a range of scenarios? Do they explain the risks and benefits of each path? This kind of decision support is a hallmark of quality independent financial advice.

Also ask about the action plan. Once the recommendations are delivered, what comes next? Some planners provide a step-by-step action plan that lists what you need to do, in what order, and by when. Others leave that to you. If you value structure and follow-through, look for a planner who includes an action plan in their service.

A useful resource for understanding how advice-only planning works in practice is the StevenFoxAO/advice-only-practice-modeling · Discussions · GitHub space, where practitioners and those interested in the model share ideas and work through the practicalities of running this kind of practice. That kind of open discussion can give you a sense of what to expect from the advice-only approach and how planners in this space think about their work.

Checking credentials and experience

You do not need to do a background check during the first meeting, but you should ask about the planner’s qualifications and experience. Do they hold a recognised financial planning certification? How long have they been working in the field? Do they have experience with clients whose situations are similar to yours? A planner who has worked with people in your stage of life or with your specific concerns is more likely to give relevant advice.

If the planner is part of a larger firm, ask who will actually work on your case. Sometimes the person you meet is not the person who prepares the recommendations. Clarify this upfront so you know who to contact with follow-up questions.

Trusting your instincts

Finally, trust your own judgment. The first meeting is as much about whether you feel comfortable with the planner as it is about their credentials and process. You are about to share personal financial details, and you need to feel that the planner respects your privacy and treats your information with care. If something feels off, it is fine to walk away and try someone else.

The StevenFoxAO/advice-only-practice-modeling · Discussions · GitHub space also contains conversations about the client-planner relationship and what to look for in a good fit. Reading through those discussions can help you refine your own questions before you go into a first meeting.

Making the decision

Choosing a financial planner is a personal decision. The checklist above gives you a framework for the first conversation, but the real test comes after the meeting. Did the planner answer your questions clearly? Did they respect your time? Did you leave feeling more informed about your options? If the answer is yes, you are likely on the right track. If not, keep looking. The right planner will make the process feel collaborative and transparent from the very first discussion.

Ends · THEPLANNINGMODEL